Posted in: Employment Law, Legal
Running a business in Spain sometimes means making difficult decisions about employees. Whether the reason is a change in the business, financial difficulties or serious misconduct by a member of staff, it is important to understand how to dismiss an employee correctly.
Spanish employment law sets out specific rules that employers must follow. Getting the procedure wrong can result in a dismissal being declared unfair, meaning the business could face additional compensation costs or other legal consequences.
There are two main types of individual dismissal that employers need to understand: objective dismissal (despido objetivo) and disciplinary dismissal (despido disciplinario).
Although both can result in an employee losing their job, they are used in different circumstances and have different legal requirements.
The first step should always be to speak to your asesor for labour matters or an employment lawyer before making a decision. They can review the circumstances, explain your options and help ensure that the correct procedure is followed.
An objective dismissal is generally used when there is a legally recognised reason for ending an employment contract that is not based on serious misconduct by the employee.
Under Spanish employment law, this may include certain economic, technical, organisational or production reasons. Or specific circumstances relating to the employee’s ability to perform their role.
For example, a business may be experiencing financial difficulties, restructuring its operations or introducing changes that mean a particular position is no longer required. An objective dismissal may be possible in these circumstances, provided the legal requirements are met and the reason can be properly justified.
Objective dismissal can also apply in certain cases where an employee is unable to perform their job adequately because of a legally recognised lack of capability. Also where they have failed to adapt to reasonable technical changes after the employer has met the applicable training and other statutory requirements.
It is important to understand that an employer cannot simply dismiss an employee under this category because business is quiet or because they would prefer to employ somebody else. There must be a valid legal reason, supported by the relevant facts and documentation.
Before informing the employee, explain the situation to your asesor or employment lawyer.
They will need to understand why the dismissal is being considered, how long the employee has worked for the business, the terms of their contract and which collective agreement applies.
They should also check whether the circumstances justify an individual objective dismissal or whether another procedure, such as collective dismissal, may be required.
The employer must be able to demonstrate the reason for the dismissal.
If the reason is economic, your adviser may need to review accounts, financial figures or other relevant business records. If the reason relates to organisational changes, the business should be able to explain what is changing and how that affects the employee’s position.
The evidence should support the actual reason for the decision. It is not advisable to proceed with an objective dismissal simply because it appears to be the easiest option.
The employee must receive written notification explaining the reason for the dismissal.
The letter should set out the relevant facts clearly enough for the employee to understand why their employment is ending. Your adviser should prepare or review it before it is delivered.
The wording matters. A letter that provides only a general explanation, without properly identifying the grounds for dismissal, may expose the employer to a challenge.
For an objective dismissal that meets the legal requirements, the statutory compensation is normally 20 days’ salary for each year of service, up to a maximum of 12 months’ salary. Periods shorter than a full year are calculated proportionately.
This compensation must generally be made available to the employee when the written dismissal notice is delivered. Or paid very shortly after. Just because the employee refuses to sign the letter does not mean the compensation does not need to be paid. It must be paid then.
There is a limited exception where an objective dismissal is based on economic reasons and the employer cannot make the compensation available because of finances. The legal conditions must be checked carefully by your adviser before relying on this exception.
The normal notice period for an objective dismissal is 15 days.
If the employer does not require the employee to work the notice period, payment in lieu of the unworked notice should be considered.
During the notice period, the employee is generally entitled to six hours of paid leave per week to look for another job.
The employee must receive any outstanding amounts owed, including salary up to the termination date and accrued, unused holiday entitlement, together with any other sums due.
Your asesor should calculate the final settlement (finiquito) and handle the relevant payroll and Social Security formalities.
A disciplinary dismissal is used when an employee has committed a serious and culpable breach of their employment obligations.
Article 54 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute identifies a number of potential grounds, including:
These examples do not mean that every incident automatically justifies dismissal. The seriousness of the conduct, the available evidence, the employee’s circumstances and the applicable collective agreement must all be considered.
For example, an employer who is unhappy with an employee’s attitude should not assume that this alone is sufficient grounds for disciplinary dismissal. There must be a legally justifiable reason, supported by the facts.
Before dismissing the employee, explain exactly what has happened to your adviser.
Provide dates, details of the alleged misconduct and any relevant records. Your adviser can assess whether the behaviour may justify disciplinary dismissal and explain what needs to happen before a decision is made.
This is particularly important where the employee has worked for the business for a long time or where there is a possibility of a legal dispute.
Keep relevant records, which may include attendance information, correspondence, incident reports and witness accounts.
Evidence must be obtained and handled lawfully. Avoid making a decision based solely on rumours, assumptions or a disagreement between staff.
Your adviser should also consider whether the employee has provided an explanation and whether the facts support the proposed sanction.
An important point that employers should be aware of is that Spanish disciplinary dismissal procedures changed following a Supreme Court judgment on 18 November 2024.
As a general rule, the employee must be given an opportunity to defend themselves against the allegations before the disciplinary dismissal is finalised. A limited exception may apply where the employer cannot reasonably be expected to provide that opportunity.
Your adviser should explain how to carry out this prior hearing, what information to provide to the employee and how to record the process.
Do not assume that preparing a dismissal letter is the only step required.
If, after considering the employee’s response, the employer decides that dismissal is justified, the employee must be notified in writing.
The letter should identify the specific facts relied upon and state the date on which the dismissal takes effect.
It should be clear and precise rather than relying on general statements such as “loss of confidence” or “unsatisfactory behaviour” without explaining the underlying conduct.
Your asesor or lawyer should review the letter before it is delivered. Keep a copy and evidence of when and how it was communicated.
A disciplinary dismissal that is legally justified does not normally carry statutory dismissal compensation.
However, the employee is still entitled to outstanding salary, accrued holiday pay and any other amounts owed under their contract or the applicable agreement.
The final settlement should be calculated correctly, regardless of the reason for termination.
Your adviser should handle the relevant payroll, Social Security and employment administration.
A disciplinary dismissal does not normally require the 15-day notice period that applies to an objective dismissal. However, the written notification and other applicable procedural requirements must still be followed.
Even where an employer believes that they have a good reason to dismiss an employee, the dismissal can be challenged if the legal grounds or procedures are insufficient.
Spanish law recognises three possible types:
The employer complies with the applicable legal requirements. A justified disciplinary dismissal does not normally entitle the employee to compensation, although outstanding employment entitlements remain payable.
The employer does not satisfy the applicable requirements. The usual consequences may include reinstatement or compensation, with the choice generally belonging to the employer, subject to statutory exceptions.
A dismissal may be declared null where it involves discrimination, violates fundamental rights or falls within another statutory ground for nullity. Reinstatement and back pay may be required.
An employee generally has 20 working days to challenge a dismissal, subject to the applicable procedural rules. Employers should not assume that the matter is resolved simply because the employee initially accepts the letter or does not immediately raise an objection.
Your asesor will help with employment administration, payroll, compensation calculations and Social Security formalities. An employment lawyer can advise on the legal grounds, evidence, procedural requirements and risks of a potential dispute.
In more complicated cases, it may be appropriate for both professionals to work together. Be sure that you understand everything you are doing and letters that are sent and always keep copies for a few years.
Before proceeding with a dismissal, ask your adviser to confirm:
It is also important to consider whether the employee is on sick leave, or has circumstances that could make the dismissal particularly sensitive from a legal perspective.
If you are considering dismissing an employee, do not rush into making the decision or communicating it informally.
Start by gathering the relevant information and arranging a discussion with your asesor or employment lawyer. Explain the circumstances honestly, provide the available documentation and ask them to confirm the correct route before taking action.
Do not backdate documents, invent reasons for dismissal or use an objective dismissal to disguise a disciplinary matter. The reason given to the employee must be consistent with the facts and supported by the appropriate evidence. Keeping proper records and following the correct procedure can help avoid unnecessary disputes and costs. Always keep relevant WhatsApp’s as well as letters and emails.
Dismissing an employee in Spain involves more than simply informing them that their employment has ended.
An objective dismissal requires a legally recognised reason, written notification, the appropriate notice and statutory compensation.
A disciplinary dismissal requires serious and culpable misconduct, supporting evidence, written notification and, as a general rule, an opportunity for the employee to respond before the decision is finalised.
If you are unsure how to proceed, speak to your asesor for labour matters or employment lawyer before taking action. Getting the advice you need at the beginning can help you make an informed decision and reduce the risk of costly mistakes.
At Molina Solicitors, we understand that employment matters can be difficult for businesses to navigate. We will provide further advice on what to do if an employee takes legal action against you.