Posted in: Employment Law, Legal
If you run a business in Spain, receiving a letter saying that a former employee intends to take you to court can be worrying. You may believe that you dismissed the employee for a good reason and followed the correct procedure. But that does not necessarily mean the employee accepts your decision.
An employee may challenge their dismissal, claim that they are owed money or bring a claim relating to their employment rights.
The important thing is not to panic or ignore the situation. You need to understand what the employee is claiming, what evidence is available and what steps you should take next.
In our previous article, we explained how to dismiss an employee correctly in Spain. In this article, we look at what happens if an employee challenges that decision and what you, as an employer, should do. Formalities in these cases must be done carefully because in the Employment Courts law protects the employees so everything has to be carried out perfectly.
There are several reasons why an employee might bring a claim against their employer.
One of the most common is unfair dismissal (despido improcedente). The employee may argue that there was no sufficient reason for the dismissal or that the correct legal procedure was not followed.
Other possible claims include:
Sometimes, the employee may have more than one claim. For example, they may challenge their dismissal and also claim outstanding salary or holiday pay.
It is important to establish exactly what is being claimed. The steps to take and the potential financial consequences will depend on the circumstances.
The first thing is to obtain advice from your employment lawyer or asesor laboral. Do not assume that the claim will go away because you believe the employee is wrong.
You should gather all the relevant paperwork, including:
Keep the original documents and do not delete messages or correspondence, even if you think they are unimportant.
Your lawyer will need to review the evidence and compare it with the employee’s allegations. This will help establish whether you have a strong defence. Also whether there are any weaknesses in the case and whether it may be sensible to try to reach an agreement.
If you have received an official court notification, pay particular attention to any deadlines and instructions. Do not wait until the last minute to seek advice. Contact a lawyer straight away
Not necessarily. In many employment disputes in Spain, an attempt at formal conciliation must take place before a claim can proceed to the Labour Court
This normally involves submitting a request for mediation to the relevant regional .service. In the Valencian Community, this is handled through the SMAC (Servicio de Mediación, Arbitraje y Conciliación).
The purpose is to give the employer and employee an opportunity to resolve the dispute without a court hearing.
At the mediation meeting, the parties may agree to settle the claim. Alternatively, they may be unable to reach an agreement, or one party may not attend. If the dispute remains unresolved, the employee can generally proceed with a court claim, subject to the applicable legal requirements.
There are exceptions where prior conciliation is not required, so lawyer will check the correct procedure for the case.
Do not underestimate the importance of this stage. An agreement reached at conciliation may avoid the time, uncertainty and additional expense associated with court proceedings.
However, you should not agree to pay compensation or sign a settlement without understanding its terms and whether it will bring the dispute to an end.
If the dispute proceeds to the Labour Court, the employee will set out the claim and the employer will have the opportunity to defend its position.
Your lawyer will help prepare the defence, identify the relevant evidence and explain which facts need to be established.
Depending on the type of claim, the proceedings may involve documentary evidence, witness evidence and other relevant material. The court will consider the parties’ arguments and the applicable employment legislation before reaching a decision.
This is why the paperwork prepared at the time of dismissal is so important. A business may have had genuine reasons for dismissing an employee, but it can still face difficulties if those reasons were not properly documented or the required procedure was not followed.
You should also understand that going to court does not automatically mean that you will lose. Equally, believing that you acted correctly does not guarantee that the court will agree with you.
If the employee is challenging their dismissal, there are three principal possible outcomes.
Procedente — the dismissal is justified
The court accepts that the dismissal was legally justified and that the applicable requirements were met.
In the case of a valid disciplinary dismissal, statutory dismissal compensation is not normally payable, although the employee remains entitled to any outstanding amounts owed.
Improcedente — the dismissal is unfair
The court finds that the employer has not established sufficient grounds for the dismissal or has failed to satisfy the applicable requirements.
In the usual case, the employer must choose between reinstating the employee and paying the legally applicable compensation. There are some exceptions.
The financial consequences will depend on the employee’s circumstances and the applicable rules. Compensation for unfair dismissal is generally calculated using the employee’s salary and length of service.
Nulo — the dismissal is null and void
A dismissal may be declared null where it falls within the legal grounds for nullity.
The usual consequences include reinstating the employee and paying the wages due for the period covered by the relevant legal rules.
A finding of nullity can therefore have considerably different consequences from a
Not every employment claim is about dismissal.
An employee may still be working for you and bring a claim because they believe they have not received the salary or other payments to which they are entitled. A former employee may also claim that their final settlement was incorrect.
In these circumstances, you will need to establish what was due and what has already been paid.
Your payroll records, employment contract, applicable collective agreement, bank transfers and signed receipts may all be relevant.
If you believe the employee has been paid correctly, your lawyer can review the figures and prepare your response. If there is an amount outstanding, it is worth obtaining advice promptly about the appropriate way to resolve the matter.
There is also an important time limit to remember: claims for amounts owed under an employment relationship are generally subject to a one-year limitation period. Although the precise calculation and any interruption of that period must be checked.
This is often the employer’s biggest concern.
The cost will depend on the type of claim, the employee’s salary and length of service. Also, the amount being claimed and whether the matter can be settled or proceeds to judgment.
Possible financial consequences include:
The financial exposure can be greater than the amount initially demanded by the employee, particularly if several claims are brought together.
It is therefore sensible to obtain an early assessment of the potential liability. This allows you to compare the risks of defending the claim with the cost and terms of a possible settlement.
You should not assume that settling is always the best option, or that defending every claim through to judgment is necessarily the right decision. Each case needs to be assessed on its own merits.
Although no employer can guarantee that an employee will never bring a claim, there are practical steps that can reduce the risk of disputes.
Keep employment contracts, payroll records, disciplinary correspondence and other relevant documents properly organised.
If an employee has performance or conduct problems, deal with them appropriately and keep a record of what has happened. If dismissal is being considered, obtain advice before communicating the decision.
Make sure that the reason for dismissal is genuine and supported by the evidence. Do not change the explanation afterwards or create documents to support a decision that has already been made.
Finally, if an employee raises a complaint or threatens legal action, do not respond angrily or send messages that could make the situation worse. Keep your communications professional and obtain advice before taking further action.
Being taken to court by an employee can be stressful, particularly for a small business where the time and expense involved can have a significant impact on day-to-day operations.
However, receiving a claim does not automatically mean that you have done something wrong or that you will have to pay the amount demanded.
The most important steps are to act promptly, keep the relevant evidence, understand the claim and obtain appropriate legal advice. If there is an opportunity to resolve the dispute sensibly, this should also be considered.
At Molina Solicitors, we understand that employment disputes can be difficult for employers to manage. Obtaining advice at an early stage can help you understand your position, consider your options and make an informed decision about how to proceed.
If an employee is threatening legal action or you have already received a claim, contact Molina Solicitors to discuss your circumstances and the assistance you may need. We can only help in the local areas of our offices, however,